Showing posts with label overaiding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label overaiding. Show all posts

Monday, March 14, 2016

Millville's More for Me Plea OR How Even NJ Education Professionals Don't Understand SFRA



There are many reasons for the persistence of NJ's unfair and irrational distribution of school aid, but one factor preserving the unjust status quo is ignorance of just how unfair the existing distribution is and how SFRA is even supposed to work. This ignorance frustrates the formation of a reform movement and allows overaided districts to lack sympathy for underaided districts and for underaided districts to not comprehend the depth of their victimization.


This post is going to be on the demoralizing ignorance some education professionals and Boards of Education have of SFRA and the basic facts of how much money their own districts are supposed to get, let alone others.

Millville's SFRA Non-Comprehension

The most recent example I've seen of this ignorance comes from Millville.

Millville is a town of 28,000 located in Cumberland County.  It is an Abbott district.  Its 6,000 students are 70% FRL-eligible but only 1% English Language Learners.

Like most other school districts in New Jersey, Millville is facing cuts for next year.  The district estimates it has a $2 million shortfall and is preparing a 4% tax increase.

Like many other districts, Millville is attributing its budget problems to the "lack" of state aid.

The district lays the blame for its budget quandary on state aid, or rather not enough of it. 
Local officials say Millville, for the sixth year, is looking toward getting state aid for its new school year that is about what it got for the current year. Officials argue that, adjusted for cost increases, the amount of money actually in district hands is declining. 
Gentile said Millville would have to close an elementary school if it gets a seventh year of flat funding.  [my emphasis]
The reporting on the most recent Millville BOE meeting is sparse, so I cannot be 100% sure of everything that was said about state aid, but complaining about flat-funded state aid seems to be something Millville did last year too.

During the meeting, Board Member Bob Donato, of the Finance Committee, spoke about the $1.8 million shortfall and the flat funding from the state.
"It's always better than taking a cut but flat funding doesn't work in the world of rising costs," Donato said.
I'm sorry that Millville has to cut its budget, but it is deeply misleading of Millville to suggest that there is a possibility that Millville will gain state aid next year.

What Millville's BOE and Administration do not know or comprehend is that according to SFRA Millville is supposed to be flat-funded.

Millville is among almost 200 districts in New Jersey that already receives more money from the state than SFRA's core formulas says it needs. Specifically, Millville's K-12 state aid is $68 million, but SFRA's formulas show that it should only receive $63 million.

Since SFRA's formulas indicate that Millville should receive less than it was getting in 2008, Millville's state aid is sustained by Adjustment Aid. Although the amounts of Adjustment Aid that districts get are divorced from the formula, Millville's BOE and Administration should realize that its $12 million in Adjustment Aid means that it isn't due for an aid increase.


If New Jersey were on a path to fully fund SFRA, Millville would be flat-funded until underaided districts catch up with it. Only after all districts get their full uncapped state aid would districts like Millville begin to see their state aid increase.

There is no justification to say "if state aid is flat for a seventh year" since Millville's aid will be flat until doomsday as New Jersey falls farther and farther from fully funding its underaided districts.

Even another Abbott verdict in which the NJ Supreme Court orders that the Abbotts get their full SFRA funding would give Millville nothing since it already gets its full Abbott funding.

True, SFRA was supposed to be fully funded in four or five years, but back when SFRA was finalized in January 2008 Atlantic City wasn't suppose to collapse, the Great Recession wasn't supposed to happen, the Pension Crisis wasn't supposed to happen, and someone like Chris Christie was never supposed to get elected.

(Update:  Little Egg Harbor is another overaided district that does not comprehend why it is not getting an increase in aid.)

Underaided Districts Don't Get It Either

Alas, many underaided districts don't understand how SFRA works either and this causes them to miss just how victimized they are.

I've seen many examples of underaided districts say that the state is shortchanging them, but then use their deficit relative to capped aid and not the much larger and more meaningful deficit relative to uncapped aid.

Red Bank Boro, one of NJ's 30 most underaided districts, is one recent example of this. At a November 2015 BOE meeting where Red Bank Boro's lack of state aid and fiscal crisis was discussed, Red Bank Boro's administrator said "the district is due another $500,000 in state aid based on student population and demographics."

NO!  Red Bank Boro was owed $6.5 million in 2015-16!!!

Lakewood's BOE president made an identical mistake in January 2016 when he desperately (and justifiably) asked the state for more assistance for Lakewood.

"If the SFRA was fully funded the District would receive approximately $5 million more than it does."

NO!  Lakewood was owed $15.8 million in 2015-16!!!

The problem with this, is that capped aid is an arbitrary, out of date figure.  Capped aid depends on how much aid a district got back in 2008; uncapped aid is the actual, meaningful measure of what a district needs demographically and economically.

Referring to capped aid figures is also incomplete because very few districts are overaided relative to capped aid whereas about 200 are overaided relative to uncapped aid.  Using uncapped aid vs actual aid gaps thus exposes the inequity of overaiding existing alongside underaiding.


When even Board of Education members and administrators do not understand how SFRA is supposed to work, what aid increases their districts can hope for, or how much aid other districts are getting there is no fuel to fire a reform movement.  New Jerseyans everywhere think their taxes are too high and their schools are being "cut to the bone," and many New Jerseyans justly blame the state for these trends.

HOWEVER, the tax and budgetary pain isn't equal everywhere and one of the disequalizing forces is the unfair distribution of state aid.  Publicizing uncapped aid amounts is necessary because it will show districts where they stand relative to SFRA's recommendations and where they stand relative to other districts.  

In the meantime, if you want to help spread the word about how bad things are in New Jersey, refer lots of people to this blog or the table of uncapped aid and Local Fair Share figures I've created here.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PWETuCGyr2rxmA98gBtLs2BwG58j8dA_3CEPAsiEpUI/edit#gid=0


Thursday, March 3, 2016

Help for the Needless: New Jersey's Richest Districts and Their State Aid


This post is the first in a series where I examine tax and Local Fair Share data for 2016-17.  This post will identify New Jersey's richest school districts, based on total Local Fair Share and Local Fair Share per student and demonstrate that most of these districts receive considerable state aid that they have no economic need for.  The conclusion is that these ultra-high resource districts' aid should be redistributed to truly disadvantaged districts.

Local Fair Share is the state's way of evaluating what taxes a district should be capable of paying in order to support its schools.  Local Fair Share is half of the calculation of Equalization Aid, the state's major stream of aid.

The formula for Local Fair Share depends on Equalized Valuation and on Aggregate Income.

The exact formula for 2016-17 is:

(Equalized Valuation x 0.013156218 + Aggregate Income x 0.046185507)/2

Equalized Valuation is the market value of all the taxable real property in a town.  Aggregate Income is the total income of the residents, although there is a three year lag in what year aggregate income is from.  For FY2017 the state is using Aggregate Income from 2013.

Local Fair Share is not confidential, but it is not published either.  I got these data by making an OPRA request of the DOE.

The definition of "richest" I am using in this post is "tax base per student." These districts do not have New Jersey's highest average incomes, nor lowest FRL-eligible rates, nor highest school spending.  By using the word "richest," I'm intentionally being provocative, but it's high time that some high-FRL districts like Hoboken accept that they are in fact rich on a per student basis.

New Jersey's highest-resource districts tend to be demographically unusual places like Hoboken and Jersey Shore microdistricts that have very high property valuations and very few children.  The few conventionally affluent districts among the richest are Alpine, Harding, and Bedminster.

As usual, I will look at state aid for these districts and show that state aid for these districts is unneeded and must be redistributed in the era of the pension crisis.

Without further ado, here goes:

These 38 districts are all the districts with more than $35,000 in Local Fair Share per student.

The Red column is the actual Local Tax Levy.

Avalon Boro, with $1.3 million in Local Fair Share per student, is the highest resource in New Jersey.  It taxes itself at 6% of Local Fair Share, but still yields over $70,000 per student.

If you examine the chart, you'll see that these are mostly tiny districts.  Of these districts, only Franklin Lakes (1,083 students), Ocean City (1,447), and Hoboken (2,596) have more than 1,000 students.  According to the figures I got from the Department of Education for estimated 2016 population, these 38 districts in total only have 12,258 students.



Helping the Needless

Unevenness of economic resources is to be expected, but what is outrageous about the situation in New Jersey is that these ultra-high resource districts get considerable state aid. The 38 richest districts get $28,555,176 in K-12 state aid, plus another $11.3 million for Pre-K in Hoboken.

23 of NJ's 38 districts with more than $35,000 per student in Local Fair Share get over $1,000 per student.

Seven of NJ's districts with more than $35,000 in Local Fair Share per student get over $3,646 per student state aid median.



I've said numerous times on this blog that New Jersey must redistribute Adjustment Aid.  I believe that the fairest method to redistribute aid is to take Adjustment Aid from overaided districts, and I make no exceptions for overaided districts with high FRL-eligibility, such as Jersey City, Pemberton, and Asbury Park.

However, another source of aid to responsibly redistribute is to take all aid away from New Jersey's wealthiest districts.  The amount of aid NJ's highest-resource districts get is in the tens of millions of dollars.  When for 2016-17 the state can only find an additional $19 million for Equalization Aid we have to look at the money the least-needy districts are getting and put it where the need is the most acute and it will do the most good.

---

See Also:


Helping the Needless: New Jersey's Richest Districts and Their State Aid

The Robbers and the Robbed: State Aid Disparities for 2016-17

Choice Districts, Charterized Districts Are Big Winners for 2016-17 State Aid

More on 2016-17 State Aid: Where the Money's Going



















Tuesday, November 10, 2015

The Most Overaided Districts in NJ (and where to find them)


This post is going to be about who NJ's most overaided districts are, how much excess money the state is sending to these districts, and where these districts are located.

My definition of overaiding is simple: any district that gets more than what SFRA indicates its demographic and economic needs are is overaided. The number I use to determine overaiding is actual aid versus uncapped aid.

There are 220 districts that get more than 100% of their uncapped aid, 112 have aid surpluses of more than $1,000 a student, 25 have surpluses over $3,000 a student and Asbury Park has the largest surplus of all, at $9,995 per student.

The following are the districts with surpluses over $2,000 a student and the amount of excess aid they get:

DistrictAid Surplus Per StudentActual AidUncapped AidExcess Aid
Asbury Park$9,995$55,407,010$31,939,334$23,467,676
Cape May Point$8,349$26,803$1,757$25,046
Dennis Township$8,165$6,161,005$1,180,315$4,980,690
Keansburg$7,008$27,334,659$17,992,774$9,341,885
Chesilhurst$6,344$2,496,590$1,583,078$913,512
Ocean Twp (Ocn Cty)$6,203$6,934,480$1,233,928$5,700,552
Pemberton$6,188$83,481,225$56,017,441$27,463,784
Washington Twp (Burlington)$6,188$672,074$258,530$413,544
Greenwich$5,667$428,348$133,652$294,696
Hopatcong$5,429$11,383,175$2,425,104$8,958,071
Estell Manor$5,043$2,125,160$1,096,449$1,028,711
Woodbine$4,680$2,969,115$1,995,703$973,412
Lower Cape May Regional$4,607$9,763,644$3,185,468$6,578,176
Allenhurst$4,387$47,745$25,812$21,933
Weymouth$4,031$2,371,540$1,444,318$927,222
Seaside Park$4,020$156,210$47,675$108,535
Hampton Boro$3,957$896,297$540,134$356,163
Eagleswood$3,599$664,182$246,644$417,538
Jersey City$3,551$418,471,290$306,778,250$111,693,040
Corbin City$3,448$698,501$460,596$237,905
Lower Alloways Creek$3,321$886,483$295,374$591,109
Tabernacle Township$3,182$5,466,194$3,098,716$2,367,478
Bass River Township$3,144$885,669$543,001$342,668
Lakeland Regional$3,085$4,828,036$1,885,356$2,942,680
Frankford$3,006$1,958,177$612,926$1,345,251
Vernon Twp$2,973$25,062,223$15,496,308$9,565,915
Knowlton Twp$2,924$1,384,951$797,196$587,755
High Point Reg$2,828$6,400,454$3,762,176$2,638,278
Frelinghuysen Twp$2,826$616,900$204,237$412,663
Great Meadows Reg$2,826$5,907,304$3,388,713$2,518,591
Upper Township$2,808$10,113,224$4,603,732$5,509,492
Highlands Boro$2,703$638,065$240,748$397,317
Springfield Twp (Burlington)$2,608$1,213,549$637,202$576,347
Hampton Twp$2,597$1,276,100$478,930$797,170
Brick Twp$2,594$35,938,828$12,676,711$23,262,117
Middle Township$2,592$13,485,581$7,667,110$5,818,471
Delaware Valley Reg.$2,577$3,997,620$1,799,575$2,198,045
Wildwood City$2,548$5,185,220$3,192,420$1,992,800
Manalapan-Englishtown$2,503$19,787,590$7,166,756$12,620,834
Bethleham Twp$2,471$1,542,185$615,738$926,447
Sussex-Wantage$2,435$7,809,249$5,040,595$2,768,654
Franklin Twp$2,414$748,291$272,670$475,621
White Twp$2,402$1,743,789$645,929$1,097,860
Eatontown$2,359$3,824,839$1,342,803$2,482,036
Logan Township$2,271$5,395,095$3,001,254$2,393,841
Little Egg Harbor Twp$2,238$9,677,667$6,734,744$2,942,923
Union Beach$2,225$8,348,950$6,493,674$1,855,276
Washington Twp (Morris)$2,151$8,042,922$3,293,025$4,749,897
Kittatinny Reg$2,107$6,042,454$3,848,561$2,193,893
Gloucester City$2,082$30,074,492$26,293,335$3,781,157
North Warren Reg$2,056$4,995,326$3,103,732$1,891,594
Alloway Twp$2,041$3,719,711$2,730,008$989,703
Washington Twp (Gloucester)$2,035$50,044,915$35,492,284$14,552,631


$323,488,605

Notice that this list isn't random.  Most of these districts are in South Jersey, often at the Jersey Shore.


How much excess money do overaided districts get?

I am not going to list all of the overaided districts, but the total excess aid is $597 million.

Where does the money go?

Drawing data from these charts:

The $597 million in excess aid is not evenly distributed across New Jersey.   In some counties, like Cape May, almost every districts is overaided.  In Union County literally no district is overaided and in Bergen, Middlesex and Essex Counties almost no districts are overaided.

Here are the net aid surpluses and deficits for NJ counties:

The above chart is simply total aid and not per student aid, but as you can see above, it is NJ's suburban counties that tend to do very poorly in aid and rural and Shore counties do well.

When you look at just the excess money the same trend of Shore and rural overaiding is still apparent, but you see Hudson County gets more excess aid than any other county.

Hudson County only has three overaided districts - Jersey City, Hoboken, and Weehawken - but Jersey City's $111 million in excess aid is more than the excess aid of any other county.


Finally, this chart shows what percentage of districts in a county are overaided.



The Savage Inequalities in New Jersey state aid only look random, but there are patterns.  Rural areas, exurbs, the Jersey Shore, and gentrified cities are privileged.  Suburban districts, be their Republican or Democratic, affluent or working class, are screwed.

See: Adjustment Aid, What It Is, and Who Gets It