Showing posts with label New Jersey Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Jersey Supreme Court. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 20, 2016

The Transformation of State Aid Since 1990


This post is about the transformation of the state aid distribution in New Jersey from the 1989-90 school year up to the present and how the Abbott II decision of 1990 has upended the state's relationship with middle-class school districts.

This is a lengthy post, so I will begin with a few bullet points.

  1. Prior to the Abbott II decision, NJ already had a progressive aid distribution where poor districts got more aid.
  2. Among poor districts, NJ already had a bias in favor of poor urban districts (the future Abbotts) over poor rural and poor suburban districts.
  3. NJ's aid increase has doubled the rate of inflation even though student population growth since 1989-90 has only been about one-third.
  4. From 1990 to 2002 NJ's pension contributions fell from $750 million to $0.  During that time state aid increased by $3 billion, from $2.5 billion to $5.5 billion. 
  5. In per student and inflation-adjusted terms, most New Jersey districts get less aid than they did before Abbott. 
  6. The districts who have lost the most state aid per student are not wealthy districts who could easily fund education with local money; the biggest "losers" are districts who have gained the most population.

Chris Christie was wrong to propose that every district get equal state aid per student, but he is 100% correct that the Abbott System is a major cause of New Jersey's property tax crisis.  ("Major" does not mean "sole").

The Education Law Center says that any attempt to link Abbott to New Jersey's property tax crisis is "scapegoating" the Abbotts, but this is just the Education Law Center insulting the intelligence of the state.

The word "scapegoat," as a verb, means to cast blame onto something that is blameless. People may believe that Abbott funding still has educational merit, but to deny that Abbott funding is a major cause of high property taxes is preposterous because the enormous money given to the Abbotts has been diverted from middle-class, working class, and poor non-Abbotts.

The early 1990s state aid data in this post have not been available online previously.  I got the state aid and enrollment data from the Department of Education via an OPRA request.  I've put everything online here.  See the conclusion of this post for more information about the data.

State Aid in 1989-1990

In 1990, when the landmark Abbott II decision came out, New Jersey's K-12 state aid total was $2,536,074,465, divided amongst 1,076,005 students, so $2,356 per student.

This amount would be $4,330 per student adjusted for inflation.

In terms of a per student average, K-12 state aid in 1989-90 was thus significantly less than it is today.  For 2016-17, $8,031,337,334 in K-12 aid is divided amongst 1.3 million K-12 students, or $6,177 per student.
 
The increase in state aid from 1989-90 to today has vastly exceeded inflation and student population growth.



As you can see, as New Jersey increased state aid in the 1990s we first diminished and then completely eliminated pension contributions.  Thus, in discussing the origins of the Pension Crisis, the surge in state aid must be cited in addition to the sales tax cut of 1992 and Whitman's income tax cut of 1994.

Although the Education Law Center implicitly demands that New Jersey continue the pace state aid increases that occurred in the 1990s and 2000s, the pace of increase was not sustainable.

A Flatter Distribution, but Still Progressive

Aside from being a significantly lower "aid effort," state aid before the Abbott II decision had a flatter distribution than today, meaning poor towns got less and middle-class towns got more.

Yet, contrary to what is sometimes said, the pre-Abbott distribution was clearly progressive and there was already a bias in favor of "urban" districts due to the Kean Administration's attempt to give more aid to districts on the Department of Community Affairs' list of "urban municipalities."

For instance, even before the Abbott II decision came out, Newark got $263.8 million, which was more than all of Bergen County and all of non-Newark Essex combined.  Most future Abbotts got significantly less than Newark did, but they got more money than towns you might call working class and more than non-urban DFG A and B districts.

For example, in 1989-90, Millburn got $476 per student ($875 per student with inflation).  Newark got $5,519 per student ($10,155 per student with inflation), so the ratio of Millburn:Newark state aid was 1:11.  Today Millburn gets $416 per student and Newark gets $14,647, so a ratio of 1:35.

A reasonable person might consider the 1989-90 distribution to be unfair since affluent districts had vastly superior tax bases and could more than compensate for inferior state aid, but the state was still trying to give more to poor districts.



The same pattern exists for Mercer County, where state aid was progressive but flatter than it is now.



What I have never seen discussed before is that there was already a bias in favor of districts the state considered urban.


Amounts are adjusted for inflation.
The Abbotts and Everyone Else

The future Abbott districts got $1,024,840,106 in 1989-90, or 40% of the total.  At the time the Abbotts had about 24% of NJ's students.

In crafting the Abbott decisions, the NJ Supreme Court disregarded analternative aid approach to raise spending in the Abbotts up to a threshold considered "adequate."  Instead, the NJ Supreme Court said that whatever the level of the spending in the DFG I and J districts was, the Abbotts had to be at or above that level.

Since Abbott aid was tied to spending in the DFG I and J districts, the state tried to restrain spending in DFGs I and J.  Jim Florio's original Quality Education Aid of 1990 "shot the suburbs in the kneecaps" by making them pay for pensions, post-retirement health care, and deeply slashed their aid, but suburban pension assumption was reversed and the aid cuts did not (initially) go as deep as what Florio had planned.

Although DFG I and J districts gained virtually no aid, since they were not restrained from spending their own tax dollars, they were still able to increase their budgets and Abbott aid increased more than Jim Florio had wanted.

Thus, Abbott spending more than quadrupled.

First Abbott Aid doubled from $1,024,840,106 in 1989-90 to $2,291,696,951 in 1997-1998, when the Abbotts reached parity with DFG I and J districts.  During those eight years, inflation had only been 29%.

Over the next two decades to 2016-17, Abbott funding would again more than double again, to $5.1 billion (counting Pre-K).  Whereas in 1989-90, the Abbotts got 40% of the state aid total, in the 2010s they get 60% of a much larger total.

The Abbotts got the lion's share of the increase, but poor non-Abbotts did reasonably well during the 1990s.  However, after 2001-02, non-Abbott aid began a multiyear stagnation.



Aid by '90 DFG 1989-90 Aid 2016-17 Aid (counts Pre-K) Percentage Increase
Abbott $1,024,840,106 $5,097,138,421 397.36%
DFG A Non-Abbott $33,026,612 $90,616,671 174.37%
DFG B Non-Abbot $193,413,331 $651,367,836 236.78%
DFG CD $206,432,630 $588,105,998 184.89%
DFG DE $305,697,001 $793,285,540 159.50%
DFG FG $220,873,914 $488,171,679 121.02%
INFLATION 94%
DFG GH $232,498,986 $431,780,101 85.71%
DFG I $196,401,926 $273,268,931 39.14%
DFG J $9,054,787 $12,979,326 43.34%

It's critical to remember that these totals conceal great variation.  Even though DFGs A through FG appear to have gained, there are districts who have lost aid in each of those DFGs, even DFGs A and B. Lawrence Township in Cumberland County was DFG A, but it has lost aid in per pupil and inflation adjusted terms.  Lakewood was in DFG B, but it has also lost aid.

In per pupil terms and inflation-adjusted terms, a majority of NJ districts have lost aid.

Of the state's $5.54 billion increase in K-12 opex aid, the Abbotts have gotten over $4 billion, or nearly two-thirds. Counting construction aid and Pre-K aid, the Abbott increase easily exceeds two-thirds.




The Biggest Losers

I hate to use the word "loser" in the context of any district, but I can't think of another antonym for "gainer" that fits.

The biggest losers in aid per student are NOT wealthy districts like Millburn, Princeton, and Mountain Lakes.  The largest losers in state aid are districts for whom aid has been flat or negative and population growth has been dramatic.

Chesterfield is NJ's biggest loser, since its population has quintupled and its aid has actually dropped. In 1989-90, Chesterfield got $523,570 for 228 students.  For 2016-17, Chesterfield will get $419,983 for 801 students.  

 Adjusted for inflation, Chesterfield has lost 87% of its state aid ($4,225 per student in '89-90, $501 per student for '16-'17)

It's possible that Chesterfield was overaided in 1989-90, but a drop of this magnitude is unacceptable unless there has been a tremendous increase in wealth.

There are in fact about 100 districts in New Jersey that have lost aid in nominal terms and these districts are not all wealthy. Cherry Hill, is the state's biggest loser in nominal dollars. It got $18,222,828 in 1989-90. Now it gets $13,110,005.



Conclusion:

The trend of state aid increases outpacing inflation was never going to be sustainable and New Jersey has to get used to a "new normal" where state aid increases are modest and often lag inflation and student population growth.

The huge surge for the Abbotts is particularly unsustainable.  Given the ineffectiveness of Abbott spending, Abbott aid should be be redistributed to other needy districts.

----

Data Note:

The state aid amounts I got from the DOE were in a very easy to use Excel format, but the enrollment data had to be scanned in manually. Since the enrollment data is formatted in a way that is not machine-readable, I have had to hand copy the data myself. Please excuse any data entry errors and try to focus on the big picture.

Also, the state has changed how it calculates enrollment for districts that have sending-receiving relationships with high schools.  The 1989-90 enrollment numbers I got did not include send-receive kids for whom the district pays tuition, although these students counted towards state aid.  The 2016-17 enrollment figures I have do include send-receive kids.  Because the 1989-90 and 2016-17 enrollment figures for send-receive districts are calculated differently I exclude them from 1989-90/2015-16 per pupil comparisons.


Thursday, October 8, 2015

Even Demographically Hoboken has No Right to be an Abbott

2021-22 Update: The Hoboken Public Schools are now only 33.1% FRL-eligible. In age, the Hoboken Public Schools are wildly skewed towards younger kids. Of the 2,990 kids officially in the district, 807 (27%) are in PreK.  

Only 0.9% of Hoboken students are now ELLs.  
The HPS is now 7.7% Black and 29.7% Latino.  It is 50.3% white.  

Hoboken's K-12 state aid for 2023-24 will be $4.7 million (not counting $2.7 mil in Choice Aid). It will still have $15.8 million in PreK aid, but PreK isn't the Abbott monopoly it used to be.

-----

In the wake of Hoboken's extreme gentrification its Abbott status has become occasionally controversial, where people ask "How a district full of luxury condos, office buildings, and hip restaurants can still get as much aid as it got when it was rotting wharves and abandoned factories?"

The defenders of Hoboken's Abbott status will usually resort to a demographic argument, where they will say that Hoboken's students are not representative of the town at large.  The core of this argument is "Hoboken's students are mostly poor, they have special needs, Hoboken therefore needs more state money."

This argument surfaced in 2007 in a New York Times article "Hoboken's Rebirth Fuels School Aid Formula Fight."  In the article Hoboken school officials used a demographic argument in favor of sustaining their Abbott status and high state aid.

In Hoboken, for example, school officials said that a majority of their students come from housing projects, not the upscale condos whose owners often send their children to private or parochial schools. Seventy-five percent of the district’s students are poor enough to qualify for free or reduced lunch, the seventh-highest level among all Abbott districts, according to state statistics. Union City is first, with 92.7 percent, followed by Passaic (84.7 percent) and Asbury Park (81.9 percent).

Even in 2007 Hoboken was making a bullshit argument. In 2007 Hoboken had $7.9 billion in Equalized Valuation for only 2200 students, or $3.6 million per student.  At the time Millburn had only $8.1 billion for 4,600 students, a "measly" $1.8 million per student.  Princeton had $7.7 billion for 3,600 students, or "only" $2.2 million a student.  Thus, even in 2007 Hoboken was richer than NJ's richest suburbs and ridiculously overaided compared to its local resources.

However, this post isn't going to address economics.  It is going to show that even if you pretended that Hoboken wasn't property rich and that Hoboken's student population wasn't very small in relation to Hoboken's overall population, that even demographically Hoboken has no right to be an Abbott district.

Falling FRL-Eligibility

Hoboken was being accurate, back in 2007 when it pointed out that it had the seventh highest percentage of students in the Abbotts who were FRL-eligible, but in 2015 this is no longer the case.  According to 2013-14 data from the Education Law Center, Hoboken's FRL-eligibility has fallen to 49%, only the 30th highest among the Abbotts.


Abbott DistrctFRL-eligibility
Camden City*95%
Union City*95%
Asbury Park City*93%
Bridgeton City*93%
Passaic City*91%
Paterson*90%
Trenton*89%
Salem City*89%
Plainfield*88%
New Brunswick*88%
City of Orange*86%
Pleasantville*85%
Perth Amboy*85%
Elizabeth City*85%
Harrison*81%
West New York81%
Long Branch*79%
East Orange*76%
Irvington*74%
Keansburg73%
Garfield71%
Jersey City71%
Vineland City70%
Gloucester City69%
Burlington City61%
Phillipsburg53%
Neptune Township52%
Hoboken49%
Pemberton44%


However, using the other Abbotts as the comparison group is deceptive since in 2007, and even more so now, there are numerous non-Abbotts which have higher FRL-eligible rates than Abbotts.

If Hoboken wanted to compare itself to all districts in New Jersey it would find itself having the 96th highest FRL-eligibility rate.


Districts with Higher FRL-Rates than Hoboken (2013-14)
Camden City*95%Gloucester City69%
Union City*95%Somers Point68%
Seaside Heights Boro94%Hillside68%
Asbury Park City*93%Ventnor City68%
Bridgeton City*93%North Plainfield67%
Woodlynne Boro93%Carteret 65%
Passaic City*91%Woodbury65%
Paterson*90%Bayonne65%
Trenton*89%Clementon64%
Salem City*89%Highlands Boro64%
Atlantic City89%Hackensack63%
Red Bank Boro89%Lawrence Township63%
Plainfield*88%Lodi63%
New Brunswick*88%Pennsauken63%
East Newark88%Cliffside Park62%
City of Orange*86%North Bergen62%
Lakewood (B)86%Burlington City61%
Pleasantville*85%Mount Holly61%
Perth Amboy*85%Linden59%
Elizabeth City*85%Penn's Grove/Carney's Pt59%
Wildwood City85%Belmar59%
Prospect Park85%Belleville59%
Fairfield Twnp (B)83%Kearny57%
Harrison*81%Rahway57%
Commercial Township (B)81%Ocean Gate57%
Long Branch*79%Clifton56%
Egg Harbor City (B)79%Lower Township56%
Guttenberg78%Brooklawn56%
Fairview77%Lakehurst55%
Freehold Boro77%Winslow54%
East Orange*76%Deerfield54%
Lindenwold76%Riverside54%
Paulsboro75%Edgewater Park53%
Irvington*74%Galloway53%
Lawnside74%Keyport53%
Upper Deerfield53%
Keansburg73%Phillipsburg53%
Bound Brook73%Brigantine53%
Haledon72%Clayton53%
Garfield71%Neptune Township52%
Jersey City71%Downe51%
Vineland City70%Glassboro50%
Millville70%Bradley Beach50%
Woodbine70%Englewood50%
Gloucester City69%North Wildwood50%
Beverly City69%Westville50%
Roselle69%Pine Hill49%
Dover69%Hoboken49%


This fall in FRL-eligibility has occurred in the last few years.

In 2011-12, 1,230 of Hoboken's 1730 kids were FRL eligible (71%).  In 2014-15, 1178 out of 1,888 were (63%).  In 2015-16 only 1021 out of 1943 were (52.5%).

Hoboken's FRL-eligibility fluctuates around 50% and is above the state average of 38% FRL-eligible, but not by a huge amount.  However, continuing membership in the Abbott list begs the question, if Hoboken must remain an Abbott because it is ~50% FRL-eligible, what about the 95 districts with even higher percentages of FRL-eligible students?  Or what about the many diverse districts, from North Brunswick to Cherry Hill to West Orange to Edison, whose average student is less poor than a Hoboken student, but whose overall affluence masks diversity and thus have many more (in absolute terms) economically disadvantaged students than Hoboken has?








An Even Lower Proportion of Poor Children in Pre-K


The  percentage of kids getting "Free" Abbott Pre-K in Hoboken who are FRL-eligible is not released publicly but it is possible to make an estimate based on how many FRL-eligible children are in the average grade in Hoboken.

Hoboken has fewer than 1,200 FRL-eligible students.


School# of FRL-eligible students
Hoboken Junior/Senior HS409
Brandt (this includes Pre-K) 2424
Calabro67
Connors225
Wallace243
Elysian Charter School37
Hoboken Charter School85
HOLA27
TOTAL1117

Since this list refers to thirteen grades, we can estimate that there are about 86 FRL-eligible students in the average grade, although the younger grades skew more affluent.

Anyway, even making an assumption that the 3 and 4 year old age cohorts in Hoboken are consistent with the rest of Hoboken's population, there are likely about 170 poor 3 and 4 year olds in Hoboken.

According to Hoboken's User Friendly Budget, there are 615 Hoboken kids in privately-run Abbott Pre-K.  According to the School Performance Report on Brandt, there are 148 Pre-K children there.  Thus, Hoboken has 615+148=763 kids getting Abbott Pre-K.  170 FRL-eligible kids (an estimate) / 763 = 22%.

(The sheer size of Hoboken's Pre-K grades is telling.  By Hoboken Jr/Sr High School the grades have only a few more than 100 kids each.  On the Pre-K level the grades have more than 300 kids each.  It's obvious that many Hoboken families just move to the suburbs after they take advantage of Abbott Pre-K.)

In any case, Hoboken is using a sleight of hand when it refers to FRL-eligible students at all since it does not want anyone to realize that it has small populations of the other categories of at-risk students, English Language Learners and students in Special Education.  It's like a pickpocket tapping your shoulder while they remove your wallet.

Almost No ELLs.

According to the Education Law Center only 1% of Hoboken students are classified as "Limited English" compared to a state average of 5% "Limited English."

This 1% figure is so small that I had to check every Hoboken school on the School Performance Reports to see if it was accurate.

Indeed the 1% figure is accurate, although it is rounded up from 0.8%.  In all of Hoboken there are only 21 ELLs, barely enough for a single classroom.


School# of ELLs
Hoboken Junior/Senior HS8
Brandt (this includes Pre-K) 240
Calabro0
Connors1
Wallace12
Elysian Charter School1
Hoboken Charter School0
HOLA0
TOTAL21

Fewer Students in Special Education than Average

Special Education classification is subjective, so the state does not use it to calculate a district's Adequacy Budget, but even here, Hoboken has fewer students with special needs than the average district.  Only 10% of Hoboken students are in special education compared to a statewide average of 13%.

Almost Entirely An English-Speaking Population

In September 2015 at a hearing on expanding Pre-K in New Jersey State Senator Mike Doherty challenged Hoboken's Abbott status.


Doherty made the point that the individuals in Hoboken have a median income of $69,000, compared to $29,000 in Hackettstown. And yet Hoboken, not Hackettstown, has a state paid-for pre-K program based on its designation as an Abbott School District. 
“You could be a Wall Street executive and before you hop in your limo you could drop your child off at pre-school paid for by the taxpayers of Hackettstown,” Doherty said.
Senator Teresa Ruiz, whose district is Newark and Belleville, responded:
“How do we bridge our achievement gap?” she said, identifying what she said was the subject at hand. “How do we expand high optimal programs? Hoboken [when designated an Abbott District] was a different community than it is today. It’s nothing we’re going to figure out today. Many Latino and African-American families needed to utilize those programs.”

This is a strange defense to make of Hoboken's Abbott status, since Abbott funding was tied to poverty and local resources, not explicitly to the size of the Latino and black populations.


In any case, Hoboken's schools are only 15% black, one point below the state average.  


Hoboken's schools are 49% Latino, which is significantly above the state's average of 24%, but Hoboken's Latinos are almost entirely English speaking. 


According to the School Performance Reports, Hoboken Jr/Sr High School is 62.7% Latino, but only 5% of students speak Spanish at home and trivial numbers speak other languages.

.  
Belleville High School is superficially similar to Hoboken, with 59.8% of students there being Latino, but 32% of Belleville students speak Spanish at home and another 9.3% of students speak other languages.  

Kearny High School is also superficially similar to Hoboken, with 56.8% of students being Latino, but 30.1% speak Spanish at home and 13.6% speak other languages.


Likewise with Guttenberg, where 88.6% of students are Latino, but 53.3% speak Spanish at home.  


No one thinks of Summit as a Latino bastion, but it is 15.9% Latino and 12% of Summit's students speak Spanish at home.  Summit has more Spanish speaking Latinos than Hoboken.  


What I am saying here is that simply because a high percentage of Hoboken students are classified as "Latino" doesn't mean they are immigrants or even second generation.  Some of Hoboken's Latino students can even be wealthy.  Since state aid is not supposed to be tied to race in any case, Ruiz is making a poor argument in defense of Hoboken's historical Abbott status.  


Attempts at Reform

Hoboken's Abbott privileges have long been controversial.  The Education Law Center's attitude towards Hoboken's Abbott status is: 
  • Once an Abbott, always an Abbott. 
In the 2007 Education Law Center executive director David Sciarra said that Hoboken could be delisted as an Abbott as long as nothing changed. 
David Sciarra, an advocate for the children of the Abbott districts, called the criticisms of Hoboken a “red herring” because the district receives so little Abbott aid. More important, he said, were the educational reforms introduced under Abbott to address decades of neglect and concentrated poverty in urban schools. One such reform is the focus on preschool programs in Abbott districts. 'The Legislature could remove Hoboken from Abbott, but it must have a plan in place to continue those educational reforms,' he said.

So Hoboken could cease to be an Abbott if he kept Pre-K and all its aid? What would the point of this be?

Hoboken's superintendent at the time, Jack Raslowsky, said the same thing.:

“The governor should not assist other districts at the expense of Hoboken or any of the other Abbott districts."

Sciarra has continued to defend Hoboken's Abbott privileges even as its wealth has grown and its baby boom has increased the Pre-K population.  As recently as 2013, at which time hundreds of New Jersey districts were underaided and the state was making no progress in ending the Abbott monopoly on Pre-K, Sciarra attacked the Hoboken BOE and state for creating waiting lists for Pre-K.

“A Supreme Court ruling made it clear there can be no waiting lists,” Sciarra said. “If additional parents want their children to attend pre-school, funding and space must be provided to accommodate the children otherwise their rights to attend the program are being violated.”
First, I don't consider a conversation about Hoboken's Abbott money to be a "red herring" because even if Hoboken "only" gets $20.8 million in Pre-K and K-12 state aid, New Jersey is broke.  For 2015-16 the increase in Pre-K and K-12 state aid was only $8 million.  I'm sure members of the Clifton Board of Education would love hearing that it's ok for Hoboken to get double the per pupil K-12 aid as Clifton since "Hoboken receives so little Abbott aid."

Also, Hoboken is not the only overaided Abbott.  According to the Education Law Center itself, sixteen of the Abbotts and another 200+ districts in fact get more state aid than SFRA economically says they need.  Although the case of Hoboken is extreme because Hoboken is New Jersey's richest district, there are echoes of it elsewhere.  


Then there is the notion Sciarra has that the "rights" of kids in Hoboken are "being violated" by only a waiting list for Pre-K when much poorer, much more disadvantaged kids in Dover, Prospect Park, Belleville, Clifton etc do not have any Pre-K at all. However long the Hoboken waiting is was, I'm sure it was not as long as the wait for Pre-K that kids in Dover are going to have. The fact that the Abbott decisions only apply to the Abbott districts is a perversity of good governance and a fatal flaw of the whole crusade to use the courts to win what could never be won through normal legislation. It is the equivalent of Brown v. Board of Education only applying to Topeka, Kansas.

The Education Law Center would answer this question about disparities between Abbotts and non-Abbotts by saying the state should fully fund SFRA, which was supposed to fund Pre-K for all children in districts where more than 40% of kids are FRL-eligible and is supposed to increase funding for poor non-Abbotts.  In other words, the Education Law Center believes the solution to Abbott/non-Abbott unfairness is to Abbottize the whole state.  

The problem with the Education Law Center is that it has no conception whatsoever that the state has a fiscal crisis.

If you read the Education Law Center's publications you'll find virtually no references to the recession, Pension Crisis, and collapse of the Atlantic City gambling industry.  The idea that New Jersey's high taxes might drive retirees and businesses out is just not on their radar.

Remember, the Education Law Center opposed SFRA in the first place because it believed it would decrease future aid for the Abbott districts.

Meanwhile, while the Education Law Center exists in a utopian realm of infinite money for education, the state is stuck in a tightening fiscal vise of Pension Debt and the eventuality of another recession.

This means that SFRA is never going to be fully funded and if New Jersey wants fairness it has to be realistic and pragmatic regarding the Abbotts, especially Hoboken. Superintendent Jack Raslowsky statement, "The governor should not assist other districts at the expense of Hoboken or any of the other Abbott districts" is more reactionary and unrealistic than ever.

Unless assistance comes "at the expense of Hoboken" it is going to come not at all.

If the state cannot realistically increase Pre-K spending it needs to spend what it has more fairly.  This means means-testing in all the Abbotts and the deAbbottization of Hoboken.  When the Education Law Center sides with Hoboken against the state it is siding with the rich against the poor and middle class.  At best, since there are some poor children in Hoboken's Pre-K and K-12 schools, the Education Law Center is siding with some of the poor against the vast majority of the poor.

But back to Hoboken, for many years now there has been no economic justification for Hoboken to be an Abbott.  During this time Hoboken's defenders maintained that its students were poor and therefore Hoboken should continue to get high aid.  This argument has been irrelevant for fifteen years given Hoboken exceptional property tax base and proportionally tiny student population, but now the demographic argument is now as obsolete as the economic one.


The First Parts of the Hoboken Trilogy:




See Also:

Dr. Anthony Petrosino's post about the departure of non-FRL families from Hoboken as children age.