Get Updates on the NJ Education Aid Facebook Page

Tuesday, April 27, 2021

New Jersey's Population Growth in the 2010s

 

One theme of this blog is that New Jersey is overtaxed and that having high taxes induces low economic growth, net outmigration, and  low population growth.

In making that argument, I used authoritative data from the US Census, such as State Population Totals and State to State Migration Flows.  For job growth, I used authoritative Bureau of Labor Statistics data.

My analysis is only as good as my data.  Unfortunately for my analysis of population growth, the Census data I relied badly underestimated New Jersey's population growth by 412,000 people (4.58%).  

Although estimates are just estimates and it's understood they aren't exact, the Census's mistake for NJ is its largest for any state.  Instead of an estimated population growth for the 2010s of +80,000, our actual population growth is +497,000.

Instead of having a population growth that was expected to be the ninth slowest in the US, our population growth was actually the 26th slowest, meaning 25th highest.  New Jersey's growth of 5.65% is thus at the median of states, and only somewhat below the national weighted average of 7.4%.

The error in the Census estimate for NJ is huge and is outside the margin of error for their reports.  For instance, for 2018-19 State to State migration, the Census estimated that 229,484 people moved out of NJ, with a MOE of +/- 11,928 and 149,260 moved in with a MOE of +/- 9,572. Immigration into NJ was 60,826 with a MOE of +/- 7,820.

Even if the move-out number was 11,928 too high, the move-in was 9,572 people too low, and the immigration was 7,820 too low, that's only 29,320 additional people in NJ, which doesn't equal the 40,000 annual "hidden population increase."



In the 2010s, instead of New Jersey's growth coming in at 16% of the national average (which would have been our worst ever), it was 77% of the national average, which is the best we've done since the heyday of suburbanization of the 1950s-1960s.

YearNJ PopulationNJ Growth Over Previous DecadeUS PopulationUS Growth Over the Previous DecadeNJ's Increase as a Percentage of US Increase
19504,835,329-151,325,798--
19606,066,78225.5%179,323,17518.5%138%
19707,168,16418.2%203,211,92613.3%136%
19807,364,8232.7%226,545,80511.5%24%
19907,730,1885.0%248,709,8739.8%51%
20008,414,3508.9%281,421,90613.2%67%
20108,791,8944.5%308,745,5389.7%46%
2019 (est.)8,882,1901.0%328,239,5236.3%16%
2020 (official)9,288,9945.7%331,449,2817.4%77%


Faced with the reality that NJ had solid population growth in the 2010s, I have to admit that perhaps my thesis that high taxes are strangling New Jersey is exaggerated.  More people are either unaffected by NJ's high taxes, tolerant of the high taxes, angry about taxes but stuck in New Jersey, or supportive of New Jersey's taxes than I thought.  

Population change is determined by three things

  • natural increase (ie, births minus deaths).
  • immigration.
  • domestic migration.


We know New Jersey's births slowed down. There were only 1,027,274 babies born in NJ 2010-2019, versus 1,143,427 in the 2000s.

We know NJ's deathcount also rose slightly, from 719,513 in the 2000s to 724,387 in the 2010s.

Thus, natural increase contributed 121,027 fewer people to NJ's population increase in the 2010s than 2000s.  

Thus, the cause of the Census's discrepancy must be a large underestimate of immigration and/or an overestimate or net domestic outmigration.  It's entirely possible that thousands more people are living "in the shadows" in NJ than anyone realized and the Census's estimates missed them.  It's also possible that the 2010 Census count for NJ was an undercount.

Although those of us who warn about the negative effects of high taxes on population growth must be humble now and rethink our positions, in terms of economic growth, the 2010s were still a bad decade for New Jersey, with our 2007-2018 income growth coming in at the country's eighth lowest.   


And job growth was the 16th lowest.




New Jersey's growth in the 2010s isn't exactly vindication of the progressive case either, since a conservative named Chris Christie was governor for eight years of that period and New Jersey's property taxes increased more slowly than in previous decades.  

If someone argues that New Jersey's average population growth validates a highly-progressive tax structure, the population growth of high-earners in New Jersey, based on verified IRS data, is still among the country's lowest.

New Jersey's growth is also highly uneven, although that is probably unavoidable. Here's our growth in Murphy's first two pre-Covid years.




Anyway, it is a time to rethink demographic, population, and fiscal conditions in New Jersey.  Are taxes are damaging as I thought?  No.  But is New Jersey still overtaxed and is our budget out-of-whack with neglect of non-PreK-12 items?  I think so.

UPDATE:

EJ McMahon presents some interesting ideas about the Census's underestimate of NJ's population:

Where are all those people?

So what accounts for New York’s estimate-census gulf? Demographic data grinders suggest at least three possible factors:
    • Since 2010, the Census Bureau has changed its annual estimation methodology in a way that resulted in a lower count of foreign immigrants, which have accounted for an especially large share of New York’s population growth over the past 40 years.
    • New York State and New York City officials provided the Census Bureau with a large number of addresses that were not in the Bureau’s master file.
    • The Census Bureau had an expanded outreach program for 2020, which for the first time included the option of filling out census forms online. The federal outreach effort was heavily promoted and augmented by immigration activist groups, subsidized by the state and city, in the New York metropolitan area.

These factors don’t explain the trends in all immigrant-intensive states, however. For example, the difference between Census estimates and the 2020 official Census in California, Florida and Texas were tiny at 0.2 percent, 0.4 percent and 0.6 percent respectively. New Jersey, on the other hand, had the largest percentage difference between its 2019 estimate and 2020 census count: 4.6 percent.


The WSJ also documents that Covid produced a huge movement into NJ from NY, although that would have mostly taken effect after the Census's snapshot day.

 

The exodus from New York City has been a boon for New Jersey. The state more than doubled its new households from migration in 2020 from the prior year. In 12 suburban New Jersey counties, net growth from relocating New York City residents rose to more than 35,000 households in 2020, up 76% from the prior year.



  


11 comments:

  1. Hey there,
    Great wonderful much appreciated If anyone want to download the latest version Rummy Wealth visit here to download the latest version

    ReplyDelete
  2. The Las Vegas Grand Prix is a thrilling addition to the world of motorsports, combining the high-octane action of Formula 1 with the electric atmosphere and glamour of the iconic Las Vegas Strip, creating an unforgettable racing experience for drivers and fans alike.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When buying skincare products for your face, look out for ingredients suitable for your skin type and concerns, and check for potential allergens or irritants to ensure compatibility and minimize any adverse reactions. Additionally, consider product claims, reviews, and recommendations to make informed decisions about the effectiveness and suitability of the skincare products you choose.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ECU Remapping is a game-changer for automotive enthusiasts seeking to unleash the full potential of their vehicles. With expert ECU tuning, this service can optimize engine performance, improve fuel efficiency, and enhance overall driving dynamics. Whether it's increased horsepower, improved throttle response, or customized tuning for specific driving preferences, ECU remapping can provide an exhilarating and personalized driving experience. For those looking to take their vehicle's performance to new heights, ECU remapping is a must-have service.

    ReplyDelete
  5. France Lotto Results are determined by a random drawing of five main numbers from a pool of 1 to 49, followed by an additional "Lucky Number" drawn from a separate pool of 1 to 10. Players who match all five main numbers and the Lucky Number stand a chance to win the grand prize. However, there are multiple other prize categories for participants who match fewer numbers, providing a range of opportunities to win.

    ReplyDelete
  6. No podría estar más de acuerdo con tus ideas, ¡lo has clavado! He estado usando el Contador De clicks y ha hecho que analizar el tráfico de mi sitio sea muy sencillo.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In an era when digital media and screens dominate our daily lives, "Melted Stories" underscores the enduring value of human connection through storytelling. It celebrates the moments when people gather around campfires, dinner tables, or virtual screens to share stories. These shared experiences, whether told through words, images, or gestures, foster a sense of unity and belonging, reminding us of the timeless power of storytelling to unite individuals and communities.https://www.meltedstories.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Kekes Menu who prefer a more leisurely breakfast experience or want to enjoy their favorite breakfast items at home or in their hotel room, Kekes typically provides online ordering and delivery services. This convenience allows customers to enjoy their breakfast from the comfort of their own space while still savoring the flavors of Kekes' delicious offerings. It's perfect for busy mornings, lazy weekends, or when you simply want to enjoy breakfast in your pajamas.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Discover how Gamification can turn your routine into an epic quest for success. Join the adventure today!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Craving a flavorful feast in Ashington? Indulge in the irresistible taste of a Hog Roast! 🐷🔥 For a mouthwatering experience and an event to remember, check out Hog Roast Ashington. Your taste buds will thank you! 😋🍖 #HogRoast #AshingtonFlavors #EventCatering

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am new to your blog and just spent about 1 hour and 30 minutes reading. I think I will frequently visit your blog from now on. I will definitely learn a lot from water purifier uae

    ReplyDelete